Joseph Kony, the Invisible Children and the rest
Joseph Kony, the
Invisible Children and the rest
A video exposing one
of the most notorious contemporary criminals and awakens youth from their
slumber has raised huge reactions and criticism. Non-Governmental Organisations
are once again targeted.
On the 5th of March a video was
uploaded on youtube and immediately became viral – which means huge success.
During only its first week it hit 70.000.000 views and became food for thought
for hundreds of other videos, posts and comments. The video’s theme is: The
last decades a basic problem in Uganda is the one regarding Joseph Kony’s
actions. With his army, the so-called Lord’s Resistance Army, he kidnaps, mutilates,
rapes and destroys. The video urges its viewers to support their organisation
called the ‘The Invisible Children’. With the moto ‘Make Kony famous’ the
organisation hopes that Politics (and more particularly the United States of
America) will take action against Kony and save Uganda. The reactions and
criticism raised are too big to be ignored. Each and every one contributes to
this discussion by giving his/her opinion and more information. This article
presents some of the criticism as well as some conclusions.
The common denominator of all the criticism is
the following: the video and the information it provides are misleading since
J.Kony actions have been halted in Uganda. Many mention that he currently
resides out of the country – possibly at Congo – or even that he is dead.
Others, maybe more extremes, support the view that the video predisposed the
public’s positive reaction to an upcoming invasion to Uganda from the United
States Army – serving in this way the politico-economic benefits of the
country. Whatever the truth may be, the unfortunate realization was that it
proved to be very easy to trick the wider public. Especially the youth appeared
to be the most vulnerable. An HD video, some moving pictures and a persuasive commentary
are enough to make the youth believe whatever Hollywood wants them to believe.
Note that many celebrities such as Rihanna, J. Bieber or Oprah support the
campaign. It is a shame that despite the good intentions of all those that
shared this video on their social media, they proved to be easy to influence,
even naïve. There is a need to filter and double check the information we get,
and this is something we shouldn’t forget.
Other critics focused not on the video itself
but more on those enthused and motivated by it. More specifically, many blamed
those who ‘shared’ that video by saying that they have been led to believe that
with this action they are contributing to saving Uganda and consequently the
world. They are not wrong, but they are not right either. This is one of these
situations where your opinion depends on whether you see the cup half empty or
half full. Undoubtedly, sharing a video on Facebook does not change much. But
it is a small change. People blame the MTV that it is creating lazy and
insensitive youth or that the youth does not care about politics. But, isn’t
the fact that someone dedicated some of his time to watch, share and discuss
that video definitely an improvement? We shouldn’t be criticizing those who
shared that video as this will only lead to their confiding in their micro world
even more. Rather, we need to build upon the interest they showed for this
tragic story, motivate them to engage with similar issues and give them more
food for thought.
Finally, many focus on the way this
organisation uses its earnings. The analysis of their financial statement
reveals high salaries and the use of only a small percentage of funding to the
‘real’ aim of the organisation. This topic is part of a broader discussion
about Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) and their financial activities.
Truly, many NGOs are not saviors and many are clearly profit-oriented. But we
shouldn’t put all NGOs in the same basket as there are many worthy ones. The
fact that some NGO employees earn good salaries need not be that highly
critised. To put it simply, to a large extent an average NGO employee works
more than a common public employee, is a scientist (with a Master degree, PhD or
publications) and is a professional dedicated to his/her noble causes. However
we should avoid dangerous generalizations: there is no reason for an NGO
employee to be paid a low salary in order to fit in to the wrong and socially
created profile of the activist.
Unfortunately the issue of J. Kony as well as
the NGO’s is too complex to be fully analysed in this article, where we only managed
to highlight some of the issues. In conclusion, in life there is no black and
white, good and bad. There are many colors in between and it is up to each
person to make up their own opinion on the topic – which
will be respected as long as it is a well-informed one.
This is my article – translated by me – as appears at http://www.popuppress.gr/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=453:o-j-kony-mko&catid=110:2010-05-09-18-46-52&Itemid=221 - The online version of the POP UP magazine!
Written on the 12 March 2012